Discussion:
Long term readers of this blog will know that I am keen on personal security from the computer perspective and also that I am keen on windows users installing personal firewalls. My friends will tell you how often my eyes roll when they ask me to fix their unprotected machines.
First I guess, a definition of personal is required here. By this I simply mean it is a software based firewall that sits on the same machine it is intending to protect. So I’m not talking standalone stuff like Smoothwall or Firestarter (both *nix based and free) and neither am I talking about the big boys of Corporate security such as Checkpoint, Cisco PIXes, Cyberguards, well the list does go on.
I hear often and long about all you need is a router and an anti-virus application (maybe an anti-malware scanner) but you should never need more than Windows provides and certainly you shouldn’t need a firewall beyond stealthing your open internet ports. Well I disagree and I will continue to do so whilst Windows maintains its inherently buggy approach to security. Beyond this I hear the so called experts say that so long as we are careful never to install or click on anything untoward then we don’t need a personal firewall.